Sunday, March 24, 2013

To keep you up to date and let you know where I am at in this process, I am including some items for you to view. Below you will find links to surveys, a list of compiled comments made by teachers, parents and students as a result of communication and focus groups, as well as the newly revised surveys I presented to my site supervisor/principal this week. I hope to get the proposed drafts back early next month, so I can convert these documents into digital surveys that students and parents can use through Survey Monkey.

Previous Student Course Survey: This is what the survey for students currently looks like. Students are given a link they can go to to take a digital survey. They are asked to select a teacher and then begin filling in responses to statements.

https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7b-uPHeiIvYLU05THVwNEJRQXc/edit?usp=sharing

Previous Parent Course Survey: This is what the survey for parents currently looks like. Parents are given a link they can go to to take a digital survey. They are asked to select a teacher and then begin filling in responses to statements.

https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7b-uPHeiIvYODVuMEtJa1RYeE0/edit?usp=sharing

Feedback from interviews, meetings, and focus groups: The feedback shown is about surveys in general and how they should be revised. There are a variety of responses regarding the implementation of surveys, the content, and general feelings. If you have questions, let me know and I can clarify.

https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7b-uPHeiIvYbHNlZ1p0dEJuQ1E/edit?usp=sharing

The revised Student Course Survey created as a result of my action research: Here are the revised surveys the Survey Revision Team came up with. These documents were developed using the data collected through a series of student, teacher, and parent interviews and focus group meetings. In addition to these changes, I have requested that we find a way to funnel survey comments into categories, so teachers know the comments being made are about "X" class. Also, I have requested that students and parents be given an explanation with examples about the purpose of surveys to encourage positive, constructive, and purposeful feedback. You will notice some similarities and many changes. After approval, these surveys will be transferred to Survey Monkey for the final look.

https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7b-uPHeiIvYOWRnejdIYnRZUjQ/edit?usp=sharing

The revised Parent Course Survey created as a result of my action research:

https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B7b-uPHeiIvYdnVxWVJVR01STVE/edit?usp=sharing

Action Research Update

In week four of EDLD 5301, I met with my site supervisor (principal) to discuss the progress of my first action research plan (Surveys). I have completed items 1-9. During this meeting, my site supervisor made a directive decision to skip the remaining items, so he could present this to the superintendent for review. After asking for feedback and seeking out any affirmations about my work, I was only given acknowledgment for my time and efforts, but my principal stated that although this is a step in the right direction, he didn't know if it was quite there, or what would happen. I am not sure what this meant, as I completed the majority of an action research plan he asked me to do within the ridiculous time constraints he gave me. I took it to mean that he wasn't sure surveys were the answer at all. As of now, I am in limbo and can only wait to see what happens next, and/or if I can complete my action research plan. I am hoping that when I become a principal, I will remember what this feels like, so I can be sure not to do this to an employee. Although the surveys can still come back and I might be able to complete this plan, it would be a shame to see my time and the time of those involved in this process be for nothing if the surveys are rejected.

I appreciate the feedback you have given to me about my plan. Your kind words of encouragement have kept me on track and keep me focused when swimming through this quagmire of red tape. I feel like my principal is beginning to come around to the idea of me doing this work, but I am a bit discouraged at times too. The lack of positive reinforcement from my site supervisor has made me question my desire to do this work in the future.

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Action Plan


My principal is new to my campus this year, so he is hesitant to let go of leadership opportunities. I have not yet got a good feel for him. Some days he is willing to talk and share, the next his mind is somewhere else. I can imaging that the job of a principal can be very demanding. He is a great administrator by book definition, but his weakness is in being supportive. I knew my internship might be challenging, so in an effort to beat the crunch at the end of this course, I read ahead in the course work to see what we were being asked to do long term. I had a feeling that my principal would be hesitant to give up any responsibly, so I worked at getting in where I could. When the principal shared with the faculty that he was going to put together a team to address concerns over course surveys, I jumped at the opportunity to take this off his plate and use this campus concern as my first action research item. Surprisingly, he agreed, but he stipulated that I had to provide him with a draft of my suggested new course surveys by the middle of March and then complete the process by the end of March. As I have been learning more about Action Research in this course, I have been working on my first action research plan. This hasn't been ideal for me, and I am sure it is not ideal for the course, but life does not always present us with ideal situations and I have taken a risk that I am hoping will pay off when this first item has demonstrated to my principal that he can let go and allow me do more work like this throughout my internship. Below, you will see my plan. Most of these items have already been completed as you will see in the timeline. I will provide the original and revised anonymous surveys for you to see when I hear back form my campus principal.


SCHOOL VISION:
Provide academic excellence by actively engaging all students in a personally challenging curriculum that is developmentally responsive and socially equitable.

GOAL: Develop a student course survey and a parent course survey that encourages student and parent participation, in collaboration with teachers, to develop learning opportunities that are engaging, personally challenging, and relevant that lead to improving student performance.


ACTION STEP(S)
PERSON(S) RESPONSIBLE
TIME LINE
START/END
NEEDED RESOURCES
EVALUATION
INTERVIEW ADMINISTRATION ABOUT THE PURPPOSE OF COURSE SURVEYS
ADAM FALLIS
FEBRUARY 25th, 2013
COPIES OF CURRENT COURSE SURVEYS
FEEDBACK GATHERED WILL BE USED TO TALK TO STAKEHOLDERS AND DEVELOP NEW SURVEYS.
HOLD FACULTY MTG #1 TO HEAR CONCERNS AND SUGGESTIONS ABOUT COURSE SURVEYS
ADAM FALLIS
MARCH 4TH
COPIES OF CURRENT COURSE SURVEYS

DIGITAL PROJECTOR AND COMPUTER
FEEDBACK GATHERED WILL BE USED TO IDENTIFY PROBLEMS AND SUGGESTIONS FOR REVISIONS.
CREATE A SURVEY REVISION TEAM COMPOSED OF PARENTS, TEACHERS, AND STUDENTS
ADAM FALLIS
BEGIN:
MARCH 4TH

END:
MARCH 6TH
LIST OF PARENT AND STUDENT REPRESENTATIVES FOR DIFFERENT SUB-POPULATIONS.
AT LEAST ONE PREPRESENTATIVE FROM EACH DIFFERENT CATEGORY IS ON THE TEAM.

HOLD A STUDENT FOCUS GROUP TO ADDRESS CONCERNS AND SUGGESTIONS ABOUT SURVEYS
ADAM FALLIS
MARCH 5TH
AM
COPIES OF CURRENT COURSE SURVEYS

DIGITAL PROJECTOR AND COMPUTER
AT LEAST ONE PREPRESENTATIVE FROM EACH DIFFERENT CATEGORY IS PRESENT.
GOAL WAS MET.
INTERVIEW INDIVIDUAL PARENT REPRESENTATIVES OF DIFFERENT SUBGROUPS
ADAM FALLIS
BEGIN: MARCH 4TH AM

END:
MARCH 6TH
PM
COPIES OF CURRENT COURSE SURVEYS

DIGITAL PROJECTOR AND COMPUTER
AT LEAST ONE PREPRESENTATIVE FROM EACH DIFFERENT CATEGORY IS PRESENT.
GOAL WAS MET.
LEAD SURVEY REVISION TEAM MTG TO REVIEW GATHERED INFORMATION
ADAM FALLIS
MARCH 6TH
DATA GATHERED THROUGH PREVIOUS ACTION ITEMS.
THE GROUP WAS ABLE TO PUT TOGETHER A LIST OF ITEMS TO ADDRESS FROM THE RESEARCH
DEVELOP DRAFTS OF NEW SURVEYS
ADAM FALLIS AND SURVEY REVISION TEAM
MARCH 6TH
COPIES OF OLD SURVEYS AND LIST OF ITEMS TO ADDRESS FROM THE RESEARCH
A DRAFT OF THE STUDENT COURSE SURVEY AND THE PARENT COURSE SURVEY WERE COMPLETED
SEND PROPOSED DRAFTS TO THE PRINCIPAL
ADAM FALLIS
MARCH 7TH
STUDENT AND PARENT SURVEY DRAFTS, COMPUTER CONNECTED TO THE INTERNET
THE PRINCIPAL RECEIVED STUDENT AND PARENT SURVEY REVISIONS.
MEET WITH PRINCIPAL TO REVIEW DRAFTS OF SURVEYS
ADAM FALLIS
MARCH 22ND
COPIES OF SURVEY DRAFTS
A MEETING WAS HELD AND SURVEYS WERE DISCUSSED
NEW SURVEYS SENT OUT TO TEACHERS VIA EMAIL
ADAM FALLIS
MARCH 25TH
COPIES OF SURVEY DRAFTS COMPUTER WITH INTERNET ACCESS
STUDENT AND PARENT SURVEYS HAVE BEEN SENT OUT TO TEACHERS
HOLD FACULTY MTG #2 TO HEAR FEEDBACK AND CONCERNS ABOUT NEW SURVEYS
ADAM FALLIS AND SURVEY REVISION TEAM
MARCH 27TH
COPIES OF SURVEY DRAFTS

DIGITAL PROJECTOR AND COMPUTER
A MEETING WAS HELD TO SHARE NEW SURVEYS. SUGGESTIONS AND FEEDBACK WERE SHARED.
GET SUPERINTENDANT APPROVAL TO ADMINISTER SURVEYS
CAMPUS PRINCIPAL: CORDELL JONES AND ADAM FALLIS
Tentative MARCH 31ST
COPIES OF SURVEY DRAFTS
SURVEYS WERE SHARED WITH THE SUPERINTENDANT
SURVEYS ARE CONVERTED INTO SURVEY MONKEY SURVEYS
CORDELL JONES AND ADAM FALLIS
April 12TH
COPIES OF NEW COURSE SURVEYS
SURVEYS HAVE BEEN UPLOADED AND ARE ACCESSABLE VIA AN ACTIVE LINK
ADMINISTER NEW SURVEYS
CORDELL JONES
MAY 20TH –24TH
SURVEY MONKEY SURVEYS
SURVEYS ARE AVAILABLE FOR ACCESS BY PARENTS AND STUDENTS
GATHER FEEDBACK ABOUT NEW SURVEYS AFTER ADMINISTRATION
ADAM FALLIS
JUNE 3RD – 7TH
TEACHERS NEED TO HAVE RESULTS OF COMPLETED SURVEYS
A REQUEST HAS BEEN SENT OUT AND FEEDBACK IS COLLECTED.
FINALIZE, OR MAKE CHANGES NEEDED TO COURSE SURVEYS
ADAM FALLIS
JUNE 7TH
NEW SURVEYS AND TEACHER FEEDBACK AFTER ADMINISTRATION
THE SURVEYS HAVE BEEN FINALIZED.


Sunday, March 10, 2013

Updated action research

I wanted to talk about my desire to do action research on the topic of parent involvement related to building trust and closing the achievement gap between low and high SES groups. This is definitely an area of concern for me, but I spoke on a topic that was of interest to me as a single topic rather than what was in my intern plan. After realizing that I would need to explore three action research topics, and after review of my intern plan I realized that it was more wise to focus in three different areas that had already been established.

1. Evaluate Parent Involvement: There are two parts to this action research: Can campus course surveys generate constructive feedback relevant to improving student achievement? Evaluate the success of the monthly Principal's "town hall meeting" as a means of generating more parent involvement.

2.Evaluate Current Programs: Evaluate special courses such as Elective Reading and Elective Math as an appropriate form of remediation? Evaluate the Dyslexia program to determine if it is meeting the needs of students.

3. Review Support Staff Responsibilities: Evaluate the role of support staff personnel as critical to student achievement. Identify requirements of the job, training opportunities, assessments and professional development. Create plans and make suggestions for improvement as needed.

These are areas of concern within my current school that I can get done in a manageable amount of time and thus make more since as action research plans during the duration of my intern plan. I do plan to revisit the previously stated action research when I have more time.

Data Data Data (action research)

This week I was taken further down the Rabbit hole of action research. I was actually glad to get the chance to hear actual professionals outside of my own "safe zone." It was a good reminder for me because I had gotten so caught up in the "action" of inquiry that I forgot how integral data was to the process. As important as data is, I have to say "buyer beware!" I commented in my assignment this week that some administrators use data alone to base their decisions on. This is a mistake! If you are not looking at the many different aspects (whole picture) involved in data collection, you could miss important, unseen factors that could be causing a skew. It is important to talk to the people, look at the systems in place, and evaluate all of the different aspects contributing to the data being collected. Don't confuse data with inquiry. It is important to look into your programs and your people before making decisions that affect them.

Another interesting topic that came up from the interviews that I saw this week was about taking research and studies from outside entities, breaking it down, and rebuilding it as your own. This is smart business. If you can find a system or program that is successful somewhere else, look at how it could benefit your organization. That doesn't mean copy and paste... Schools are like ecosystems, you can't just introduce a new kind of water and expect things to "clean up." Sometimes that new water will contaminate and cause more harm. You have to look at the needs of your ecosystem and carefully consider what you are introducing.